Tuesday, June 18, 2019

On This Day: "An Umpire's View of Girls' Baseball"

On this day in 1944, the Milwaukee Journal published a very interesting take on the All-American Girls Professional Ball League.

Journal Sports Editor R.G. Lynch had an ongoing column titled "Maybe I'm Wrong", in which he would expound upon the sports subjects of the day. On June 18, 1944, he turned nearly the entire thing over to a verbatim interview with visiting umpire Bob Kober, in town to officiate a game between the hometown Milwaukee Chicks and the Rockford Peaches.


Kober's perspective is interesting. He was a veteran umpire who had spent nearly twenty years calling balls and strikes in the minors. Now he was behind the plate in the AAGPBL, a unique perspective to be sure.

Here's what Kober had to say:

Maybe I'm Wrong
By R. G. LYNCH
[Sports Editor]


A Veteran Umpire's View of Girls' Baseball


After 19 years of umpiring minor league baseball, Bob KOber finds the brand of ball played in the All-American Girls' Professional league a bit strange, more exacting for the umpire but "very interesting." Kober, who umpired in the American association in 1935-'36 and spent the last seven years in the Southern association, came to town Friday to work the series between the Milwaukee Schnits and Rockford. He said that he passed up a chance to umpire in the International league, "because I knew the trials and tribulations of baseball and thought I'd see what this new league was like—and I'm not sorry I did. In men's baseball," he said, "the pitch is overhand or from the side and you have time to look it over, but in this girl's game the distance is so short that you can't turn your head for a second, you've got to keep your eye on the ball all the time, and it looks as if it comes out of the ground because the pitch is underhand.

"The plays on the bases are closer, too. The base lines are shorter and the ball doesn't travel as fast as a baseball, so the ball and the runner get there about the same time. We have more close ones to call and plays are more complicated. In baseball, you know what the men will do, pretty well, but you can't tell what the girls will do. You can't loaf a minute. I never saw a soft ball game until I went to work in this league, and when I opened at Racine I knew I was in for something, but I sure like it.

They Play Hard

"It's a real game. Anyone who goes to see it once will go again. The girls play harder than men. They put their heart and soul into it and they cry when they lose. A little girl named Audrey Haine, with Minneapolis, allowed only three hits in one game. Then a ground ball was hit to her and she threw wild to first and lost the game. She cried like a baby. Bubber Jonnard (Minneapolis manager) told her that big leaguers made wild throws, but she kept on crying.

There are some ballplayers in this league that if they were men they'd be worth $150,000. Dorothy Schroeder, South Bend shortstop, is only 16, but if he doesn't handle the ball like Charley Gilbert or Donie Bush my name isn't Kober. I'll bet money you have shortstops in the American association who can't play like she does, she fields and throws like a man, and a damned good one. Go out and see her. Bonnie Baker, the South Bend catcher, handles herself just like Muddy Ruel. She's classy. You've got a dandy catcher on the Schnits in Dorothy McGuire, and a player in Merle Keagle that stands up at the plate just like Rogers Hornsby.

"There are four or five real stars on each team, and the rest are coming along. Boys who worked in the league last year say the four old clubs &mdash Racine, Kenosha, South Bend and Rockford—have improved 60%. Your Milwaukee team and Minneapolis will improve, too. These girls are used to soft ball, and they have to adjust themselves.

Heartfelt Rebukes

"This league is a high class outfit. The players are paid better than men in the lower minors, and some get more than a good many do in the American association. The people who run it are high class and it is handled that way. You'd be surprised at the crowds we play to in the four cities who had the girls last year.

"Things are a lot different for umpires. You don't get the cussing and the riding you get in baseball, but you get things that make you feel worse. In baseball, when a player yells 'Open your eyes, you blind sob!" you just get mad. In this game I've had a girl say 'I'm giving you a dirty look, Mr. Umpire.' And I've had one come up and say 'Mr. Umpire, you didn't treat me right. You could have called me safe. I had a tie.' And an old lady at Racine stopped me to say, 'Aren't you ashamed of yourself for calling that little girl out at third?'"

SOmetimes a thing like that get you, because you know they really mean it.
Fascinating. Obviously Kober isn't a completely objective observer, as an employee of the league. But even so, it's interesting to see how he, or the league, or both, are selling the game to the Journal's readers.



On This Day - "The Camera Beat the Play"

On this day in 1944, the Milwaukee Chicks of the All-American Girls Professional Ball League were playing a double=header at Borchert Field.

They had originally been scheduled to play a four-game series against the Rockford Peaches, but bad weather had forced the cancellation of the first two games (including the initial tilt, when a storm had torn off part of Borchert Field's roof during the seventh inning of a Brewer game). Readers of the Milwaukee Sentinel were treated to this quarter-page ad promoting the games:


The AAGPBL certainly went all-out promoting the Chicks. The Brewers never had this kind of treatment. Of course, with four decades of history behind them, the Brewers didn't exactly need it.

So with the skies cleared and the storm damage cleared away, the games could resume. Although the Chicks might have wanted just one more rain check.


Is there anything more exciting than a play at the plate? The Journal's camera caught this one as it happened, with Chicks backstop Dorothy Maguire guarding the plate.

The camera beat the play Sunday as Jo Leonard of Rockford slid into home plate at Borchert field in the second inning of the first game of a double header with the Milwaukee Schnits of the All-American Girls' Professional Ball League. A second later, Catcher Dorothy Maguire of Milwaukee put the bal on her and Umpire Al Gembler called her out. Milwaukee lost, 6-5.
—Journal Staff
And talk about "dirt in the skirt". This is how the players got their famous "strawberries", sliding into home plate with only satin tap pants for protection. The sweet-sounding name belied the gruesomeness of the injury, nasty scrapes with dirt ground in.

The Chicks lost the first game 6-5, but managed a split by taking the second and final game of the series, 3-0, on RBI singles from third baseman Doris Tetzlaff and first baseman Betty Whiting.


This brought Milwaukee's record to 10-13, or .435, good for fifth place in the six-team league. The Chicks would have to step up if they wanted a shot at the AAGPBL post-season.

Monday, June 17, 2019

1943 AAGPBL Scorecard on eBay

This 1943 AAGPBL scorecard is currently up on eBay, and although it's from the year before the Milwaukee Chicks entered the league, it's essentially the same as was used in 1944, which certainly makes it worth a look.


I've only ever seen one 1944 scorecard, just enough to know how similar it is to this example.


The cover art by Otis Shepard is gorgeous. A master of mid-century design. This cover was kept virtually the same for 1944, with a slight change to the league's name.

   
1944 scorecard cover
Founded as the All-American Girls Softball League, as seen here, they changed the name midway through the 1944 season to the All-American Girls Baseball League, or AAGBBL. That was better, and illustrated the desire of Wrigley and Company to move away from softball into baseball rules, but it still wasn't perfect.

When the 1944 season opened, the name had been tweaked again to the All-American Girls Professional Ball League. This initially gave us the AAGPBL shorthand, which endures today in the name All-American Girls Professional Baseball League.

The name was changed, and a price—one thin dime!—was added to the cover, but the stunning airbrush art was untouched. As it should be.

Inside, the four teams are listed and the spaces left blank for fans to fill in. This cost-cutting measure allowed the league to print one single score card for all league games.


Again, this is identical to the score cards used in 1944, with the addition of the two new teams in Milwaukee and Minneapolis.

Three players listed here would go on to be Chicks in 1944; Clara Cook from the Kenosha Comets, Gladys Davis of the Rockford Peaches, and Dorothy Maguire of the Racine Belles. In addition, Racine's Dorothy Hunter would hang up her spikes to became the Chicks' chaperone, and Rockford's manager (and Milwaukeean) Eddie Stumpf would become the club's general manager. It's likely that these are the Opening Day rosters, and don't reflect call-ups during the season, but it's surprising that so few Chicks had experience in the league. Of the twenty-four players listed in the AAGPBL's records for the 1944 Chicks, twenty-one of them were rookies that year.

On the score card's back cover, the league makes its pitch.

YOUR very presence in this park at this time makes you an active participant in a progressive movement which puts girls softball in its rightful place among the major American sports. In this park you will see fast, thrilling games played by the greatest girl softball players in America.

★

Now . . . with America straining physically and mentally to carry a larger burden than ever before, the All-American Girls Softball League becomes an important part of the war effort. As a sports spectacle, the games you see here cannot be surpassed. As healthful recreation, this sport carries its benefits right back to the work bench or to the desk or the production line. Patriotism and girls softball go hand in hand.

★

The All-American Girls Softball League, a non-profit corporation, was formed to create new, high standards for the game and to develop girls professional softball along sound lines, providing wholesome, exciting entertainment. Girls softball, as played by the teams in the All-American Girls Softball League, is the spirit of 1943 in sports. It's a great game to watch or play. So plan to spend as many of your leisure hours as you can right here in your favorite ball park.

Attending softball games as patriotic duty. I love it.

This inspiring message is closed with a look at the league's original logo. Although they may have continually changed the initials, the basic logo stayed virtually the same. The AAGPBL Players Association even uses it today, with slight modifications.

This score card is an amazing artifact of the league's first year. It will become an important part of somebody's collection, although I'd love to see it in a museum.

$399.99 is a bit steep for me, at least for a 1943, but if anyone knows of a 1944 score card becoming available, let me know.

Sunday, June 16, 2019

On This Day - "The Boss Speaks"

On this day in 1944, the Milwaukee Chicks of the All-American Girls Professional Ball League found themselves temporarily unable to play a scheduled game against the Rockford Peaches.

The night before, a storm had torn off part of Borchert Field's roof during the seventh inning of a Brewer game. The Brewers had to postpone the rest of that one game but were otherwise unaffected, as that was their last home game before a three-week road trip. The Chicks, on the other hand, were supposed to play that very next day.

The Chicks converted their Friday night contest to the first game in a Saturday double-header. But while they might not have been able to play, that didn't mean the women couldn't practice, as captured by the Milwaukee Sentinel's photographer:.

THE BOSS SPEAKS

Max Carey, pilot of the Milwaukee Chicks of the All-American Girls' Ball league, gives a few fine pointers on the art of playing first base to Betty Whitting, the handy Ann of the team, who is filling in at the initial sack after Delores Klosowski suffered a fractured ankle. Looking on are four newcomers to the team, left to right: Shortstop Pat Keagle of Phoenix, Ariz., Center Fielder Vicki Panos, Edmonton, Alberta, Can.; Third Baseman Doris Tezlaff, Watertown, Wis., and Pitcher Clara Cook, Elmira, N.Y. The Chicks open a lengthy home stay at Borchert field Saturday afternoon with a twin bill scheduled against the Rockford Peaches, managed by Jack Kloza, former Brewer slugging ace.
Sentinel photo.
The Chicks had been banged up for some time, interesting to see Carey's reinforcements arrive.

"Initial sack" is rarely seen these days, but shows how desperate sportswriters can be to avoid the standard list of synonyms.


Funny - over Ms. Whitting's left shoulder you can make out the wreckage of the first base grandstand roof awaiting cleanup.


The Orchard would be ready to go on Saturday for the first game of the double-header. And so were the new ballplayers. But Mother Nature had other plans for Mother Carey's Chicks, raining out Saturday's double-bill and giving Milwaukee one more day to rest and recover.

Saturday, June 15, 2019

On This Day - Raise the Roof

It was seventy-five years ago today, on June 15, 1944. The Chicks were on the road, and the Brewers were playing a home game against the Columbus Red Birds, when a wind gust tore loose a section of Borchert Field's roof.


The Brewers game, tied 5-5 in the seventh, was postponed, and the Brewers headed out for a three-week road trip. The Chicks were due to play the Rockford Peaches on Friday the 16th, but their Saturday game was instead turned into a double-header, and the old Orchard would be cleaned up and open for business Saturday morning.

Wednesday, June 12, 2019

"For the Boss", 1944

We're going to step outside our "On This Day" exploration of the Milwaukee Chicks for today, to recount a moment of serendipity that struck me.

I had a wonderful conversation today with the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League on Twitter. It was kicked off by this tweet:


Fantastic picture, no? I remembered seeing something like it, this photo from the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum in Cooperstown, obviously taken at the same time, where Carey and Hunter are joined by Chicks second baseman Alma Ziegler (who is herself the actual subject of the second photo):

A black-and-white photograph of chaperone Dottie Collins (left), manager Max Carey (middle), and player Alma Ziegler (right). Ziegler is a Milwaukee Chicks uniform, while Carey and Collins are in street clothes. Carey is holding the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League championship trophy. On the trophy, the names "Max Carey" and "Milwaukee Chicks" are visible.
But still, something didn't seem right. I looked through my notes and realized that the Hall of Fame's caption wasn't quite accurate.

That isn't the 1944 AAGPBL championship trophy. It was made by (or on behalf of) the Chicks players, and presented to their manager in a pregame ceremony on "Max Carey Night" at Borchert Field. Here's how the Milwaukee Sentinel covered it:

FOR THE BOSS—The Chicks, who have great admiration for their boss, Max Carey, topped off the Carey night celebration last night at Borchert field by presenting the Milwaukee manager with a combination trophy and plaque. Left to right: Alma Ziegler, Merlo Keagle, Dorothy Maguire, Thelma Eisen and Carey. The Chicks also presented Carey with the second half flag by beating Kenosha, 5 to 4.
Sentinel photo.
Gorgeous. We'll talk more about "Max Carey Night" when we get to that part of our "On This Day in 1944" series this September. But in the meantime, we can take a closer look at the trophy itself.


It's topped with a female figure at bat. At the bottom, the words "MILWAUKEE CHICKS 1944". I can't make out the long vertical plaque, but that could be a list of the Chicks players.

The main plaque is of great interest.


I can only make out a few of the words, but the Sentinel's coverage gives us the full inscription. It reads
TO
MAX CAREY
above a picture of a chain, and this text:
UNBROKEN UNSULLIED
THIS CHAIN SHALL ALWAYS BE A SYMBOL OF
STRENGTH UNITY AND VICTORY
According to the paper, Carey would have his players form a circle before every game, holding hands in a chain as he would recite those words to them. The women obviously took his mantra to heart.

And there we go. Not the 1944 Championship trophy, but something more personal, and possibly even more special. I wonder where it resides today?

You never know what might inspire your research, or where you might find a wonderful story. Sometimes all it takes is the right tweet to send you on your way.

Monday, June 10, 2019

On This Day - "We Regret to Inform You"

If you've seen A League of Their Own, you probably remember the scene.

It begins with a telegram from the War Department, a locker room full of nervous players, and the terrible dawning realization that somebody's husband would never be coming home.


The camera starts on Dottie before panning across the women, each hoping against hope against hope that the telegram isn't for them. Manager Jimmy Dugan takes it from the callow Western Union man and walks down the line. We are led to think it's for Dottie, our hero, but Jimmy instead gives it to Betty, who is led away in tears by the team chaperone. It's one of the most dramatic, and memorable, scenes in the entire film.

What you might not realize is that the scene has its origins in history. The history of our very own Milwaukee Chicks.

The player in question was Chicks catcher Dorothy Maguire. Born Dorothy McAlpin, she was one of the few Chicks with actual AAGPBL experience in 1944, and championship experience at that; she was the catcher for the 1943 Racine Belles, who had claimed the inaugural league title.

She was also married, to Corporal Thomas J. Maguire, Jr., stationed in Europe. The couple had been married in May of 1941, when they lived in a very different world.

On June 10, 1944, seventy-five years ago today, the Chicks were in Kenosha to play the Comets. Before the game, Maguire took a phone call from her mother, who told her the news: Tom had been reported killed in action. Unlike the film scene, Maguire received the news privately, and decided not to tell anyone until after the game.

The Chicks lost that day 11-7, although Maguire herself recorded a hit. She told her teammates in the locker room after the game, and the press shortly thereafter. The Milwaukee Sentinel noted her story in its coverage of the game the following morning:


The Journal went a step further in the afternoon, giving Dorothy the headline (albeit with a typo in Tom's name):


In a plot twist too bizarre for Hollywood, two months later Dorothy received a letter from Tom. He hadn't been killed after all, only badly injured and having lost his dog tags. When he returned home, he "vehemently pressed Dorothy to quit baseball to settle down at home." She kept playing, and they were divorced in 1945. Three years later, she married George Chapman, with whom she had six kids, including current AAGPBL Players Association president Rick Chapman.

Sunday, June 9, 2019

On This Day - the Chicks Become the Chicks

On this day in 1944, something momentous happened to the Milwaukee Chicks of the All-American Girls Professional Ball League. That was the day the Chicks became the Chicks.

The question of what to call the team had been percolating for some time. The league itself just used "Milwaukee", in the style of the times. Nicknames were more casual in the first half of the twentieth centuries, more transient, and were often linked to moments in time. When Cleveland was managed by Napoleon Lajoie, they were known as the "Cleveland Naps." When four starting players got married in the off-season, the papers started referring to Brooklyn's National League club as the "Bridegrooms". The Brewers had been the Brewers for forty years, more or less, but hadn't put their nickname on uniforms until 1942. And since the AAGPBL didn't wear team names on their uniforms, only city and state, it would make sense that the nickname could arise organically.

The Milwaukee Journal settled on a nickname fairly early%mdash;the "Schnitts", after the Bavarian term for a half-glass of beer&Mdash;but the Sentinel took some time to find a name they liked. They started with "Brewerettes" and "Brewettes", used almost interchangeably, as seen in these clippings from June 6th, 7th, and 8th, 1944.




And then, on June 9th, something amazing happened. Buried on the sports page...


if you can find it...


was this off-handed reference, buried in the third paragraph of an article about the previous day's games.

Manager Max Carey of the Milwaukee Chicks announced he had signed Clara Cook, a pitcher from Elmira, N.Y. She formerly hurled for Kenosha.
And there you have it. The Sentinel had settled on a name.


Ostensibly, the name referred to a 1938 RKO Pictures film, well-known at the time and based upon a 1911 novel. "Mother Carey's Chickens" was a melodrama about a widow striving to provide for her four after her naval captain husband is killed in the Spanish-American war.

"Chicks" in the story referred to her whole brood, two boys and two girls. The term as slang for children in general is as old as Shakespeare. The etymology of "chick" as a term for a young woman specifically is unclear, but it was certainly in use by 1944. Not always with a positive connotation.


Someone at the Sentinel took note of manager Max Carey's name, and applied to the film title for a world-class pun. And that's the name that stuck. It would become the name the team would use, even if only casually. The newspaper ads would continue to use "Milwaukee" or "Our Milwaukee Team", but the name "Chicks" would become official soon. Perhaps "Schnitts" was too close to another rude term, and frankly the less said about either "Brewettes" or "Brewerettes" the better.

"Chicks" may seem dismissive to our modern ears, as both the book and RKO Radio Picture have faded into historical obscurity and we're left without context. But that's how the women referred to themselves, and it all started seventy-five years ago today.

Friday, June 7, 2019

Julio Acosta, 1944

We have a lot of Milwaukee Chicks coverage this year, in honor of their 75th Anniversary, but that doesn't mean we're forgetting the Brewers. This is Brewer hurler Julio Acosta, photographed in St. Paul, Minnesota.


This was taken at Lexington Park in St. Paul, when the Brewers were in town to play a four-game series against the Saints.

Acosta had been signed by Bill Veeck the previous season. Acosta had a particularly flamoyant Milwaukee debut, courtesy of Sport Shirt Bill's showmanship: he burst out of a 15-foot cardboard cake wheeled out to home plate and presented to Brewers manager Charlie Grimm as part of a birthday celebration for the Milwaukee skipper.

Couple details of the uniform that stand out to me.


Look at the curve on his brim! That cap looks well worn-in. It's a bit hard to read the red felt "M" against the blue wool in this print.

Acosta is wearing the Brewers' road gray flannels. This uniform is unique in Brewers history for a total lack of blue on either the jersey or pants, featuring instead red script and numbers outlined in white. Veeck's first stab at a road uniform was unveiled in 1942, solid blue head-to toe with red details trimmed in white. This unique look had led to a lot of ribbing from the other teams in the American Association, and for the next season the Brewers had lifted the red-and-white patches from their blue uniforms and sewn them on to a more traditional gray.

Underneath his jersey, Acosta is wearing an undershirt with white sleeves, a style that was popular at the time and now reads as iconic of its era. White sleeves were very much the standard in the early decades of the twentieth century, but by 1951 all major league clubs had adopted colored undershirt sleeves.

Posed with his arms raised in a wind-up motion, you see that the red soutache sleeve stripe doesn't go all the way around, leaving about an inch-long gap under his arm. You can also clearly see his underarm gussets, offering greater range of movement.

Curious how he's wearing his belt, with the buckle all the way to the side.


We see this from time to time on ballplayers, especi but I don't know if I've ever understood the reason behind it. Was it a comfort thing? Did he appreciate the rakish style? I honestly don't know.

Acosta didn't pitch in that series against the St. Paul Saints; the 25-year old hurler had lost a close one to the Minneapolis Millers on June 21st, as the Brewers began their road swing through Minnesota, and his spot in the rotation wouldn't come up again until the Brewers had headed home to Borchert Field. Acosta ended the 1944 season with a 13-10 record and 3.89 ERA.

Thursday, June 6, 2019

On This Day - D-Day!

Throughout this summer of 2019, we've been following the 1944 season of the Milwaukee Chicks as it happened, as they begin the All-American Girls Professional Ball League season. But seventy-five years ago today, the newspapers were full of other news, and baseball at all levels took a back seat to unfolding world history.

Shortly after sunrise, on June 6, 1944, while Milwaukeeans at home were asleep in their beds, Allied forces were landing on French beaches in the largest seaborne assault in history.


D-Day was enormously successful, if costly, and even at the time it was understood that the sacrifice of those troops was laying the foundations for the eventual Allied victory.

Thanks to those newspaper reports, and out of respect for global events, organized baseball at all levels canceled its slate of games that day. The All-American League was no exception.

Schnits Cancel D Day Contest

Two Infielders Signed

The Milwaukee Schnits game at Racine Tuesday night in the Girls' Pro Ball league was canceled because of the invasion. Four Schnits are injured. Pitcher Connie Wisniewski twisted her knee at South Bend Sunday and will be out a week. The others nursing injuries are Vivian Anderson, third base; Alma Ziegler, second base; and Thelma Eisen, left field.

Doris Tetzlaff, Watertown, Wis., joined the Schnits Monday and will replace Miss Anderson Tuesday night against the Belles at Racine. Miss Wisniewski will be out a week. The others will be ready Tuesday night.
The Chicks had an unexpected off-day. The timing was fortuitous, allowing them to nurse their injuries, but it seems unlikely that was much of a concern. No doubt the women found their thoughts turning to the beaches of Normandy, where their husbands, brothers, fathers and friends were laying down their lives in the service of freedom.